Main
Home / News
[SaC]Peppe's
 Server Watch

<tWt> WOTmap
Forum List

Downloads
Patches
Utilities
Game & Demo
Review Criteria
Submit Levels
Mods
Levels Archive - 240
  Arena80
  Balefire Arena16
  Citadel51
  Balefire Citadel42
  Hold the Citadel5
  Magic Circle11
  Shadowed Destiny14
  Single Player11
  WOT20032
  Misc8

Network
Wheel website
WheelofTimePC on Facebook
WoTFPS on Facebook
WheelofTime on Reddit
WoT fansite on Facebook
Tar Valon website
WOTClans.com gone
WOTMaps.com gone
WOTmania gone
Planet WOT gone
Wheel of Time gone

Game Info
General Info
Strategy Guide
SP Game Hints
Interviews
Troubleshooting
Story Line
Characters
Enemies
Ter'angreal
Screen Shots
About the Books
Links

Editing
UnrealWiki
Troubleshooting
Tutorials
Utilities
Textures
Editing Forum
Review Criteria

Site Info
Staff
Staff Login


website page counter

  The Original ShadarLogoth.com Level Review Criteria

Level Review Criteria
by The Guardian and Demandred.

Each category is scored from 0-10. The criteria given below are general guidelines for reviewing, and are not absolute. Note that each category is only listed up to 9: a score of 10 is reserved for those levels which have achieved near-perfection in that category. The level named next to a category is one that would score a perfect 10. Add up scores for final score out of 100.

-Geometry (20):
General (10): Kingdom Come
1 - A single box room
3 - Multiple box rooms
5 - Multiple rooms, simple shapes (box, cylinder)
7 - Many rooms, levels, stairs
9 - Complex series of rooms and passages
Detail (10): Soulbox
1 - Boxitis
3 - Boxitis with some minimal effort to disguise it
5 - Realistic looking, but plain
7 - Realistic looking
9 - The hard stuff like Vaulted ceilings etc.

-Textures (10): Soulbox
1 - Only one texture
3 - Very poor texture choices or placement
5 - mediocre texture choices, poor placement, alignment problems
7 - good texturing, some variety, generally good alignment
9 - awesome texturing possibly including new textures or textures used in new ways

-Lighting (10): Soulbox
1 - Zonelight
3 - Point lights with no apparent source
5 - Simple sourcing
7 - Complex sourcing, different kinds
9 - Coronas and lensflares well done

-Sound (10): Soulbox
1 - What is sound?
3 - Default sounds only
5 - Some attempt made to add sounds (sprayers, etc)
7 - Good use of point sound sources OR ambient sound
9 - Good use of point sound sources AND ambient sound

-Angreal Placement (10): Kinslayer's Spire
1 - Basic or poor angreal placement, default pools
3 - Standard placement, little or no modification to pools
5 - Standard placement, modified pools
7 - Good placement including interesting use of spawn pools (ie single TA spawns)
9 - Think: Hidden TAs, new or unusual combos in the level...

-Playability (40):
Scripting (10): Soulbox
1 - Not pathnoded, insufficient playerstarts
3 - Very few pathnodes and playerstarts
5 - Sufficient Playerstarts, broken pathnoding
7 - Good playerstart and pathnode location
9 - Got the triggers working nicely too!
Theme (10): Soulbox
1 - Theme? What Theme??
3 - Inappropriate or poor theme selection
5 - Good theme, mediocre implementation
7 - Great theme, excellent implementation
9 - I don't think we're in Kansas anymore! (Editor's note: I didn't write that)
Play Style (10): Soulbox
1 - Crowded or too open. Possibly framerate problems.
3 - Confusing to move through the level. Possibly framerate problems.
5 - More of the same. Nothing really interesting.
7 - Possible to use several different play styles (ie. Camping, running)
9 - Forces or allows a new kind of playstyle (See Dropping people into a Soulbox)
Fun Factor (10): Balefire 101
1 - Try it once, throw it out.
3 - Fun for a while, but with limited appeal or gets old quickly.
5 - A standard level, fun to play when bored with the usual ones.
7 - A fun level, frequently playable. Should be standard on server rotations.
9 - Very fun for everyone, rarely gets boring.

The exact application of this scoring system to each individual level may vary, but in general these descriptors should apply.


This site is not made by, and is in no way sponsored by, Legend Entertainment or GT Interactive.
If you are looking for the official Wheel of Time site, please visit WheelofTime.com.